Tuesday, 11 June 2024

Media and Politics - 27 May 2021

 

Media and Politics

Lionel Bopage

Mass media influence the way facts are viewed in society. Independence and pluralism in media, critical public opinion and views about those in power are the safeguards of a healthy democracy. It is the historic responsibility of journalists to report the realities of everyday life on a factual basis. But such principles are dead and gone. The space for debates, disagreements, or intelligent discussion is limited. The mission of media conglomerates appear to be destroying thinking voices and analytical writings.

The media’s power does not lie in its ability to shape public opinion, but in the selection of stories for its audience and setting up the agenda for them, by Constructing Public Opinion or Manufacturing Consent. For many decades now, mass media appear to be only doing this following decisions made by the owners and ruling elites.

Market monopoly controls the media today. In the USA and the rest of the world, six companies control about 90% of media. For example, a leading multinational mass media and entertainment company Walt Disney mainly contributed to shaping American politics. The News Corporation of Rupert Murdoch has media and publication outlets in five continents.

Australia

The reality of economic survival depends on how big the businesses are. For this, media companies rely heavily on advertising and government assistance in the form of donations or tax breaks. In the 1900s in Australia, 17 owners controlled 21 dailies. In the seventies, there were only 4 owners completely controlling the remaining fifteen major city dailies , several weeklies and specialist papers. Currently News Corp Australia owns about 142 newspapers  and publishes about thirty magazines Australia wide.

In 2007, John Howard’s government scrapped foreign ownership limits, and relaxed cross-media ownership rules allowing the possession of two out of three media types. Horizontal and vertical media monopolies expanded with time. In addition, Rupert Murdoch, owner of News Corp., built his media empire by lowering the journalistic quality. Murdoch has been alleged to “go downmarket” to sell the news using scandals, violence, or sex. Despite this degradation, it brought him tremendous success.

Sri Lanka

In Sri Lanka, political affiliations of many media owners are difficult to assess. The law does not limit media ownership concentration. There are no regulatory safeguards that prevent cross-media ownership concentration. There are no conflict-of-interest legal provisions that would prevent Members of Parliament or their family members from owning shares in media organizations. Media owners are not obliged to disclose political affiliations. The state plays a key role in the media market not only as an owner but also as the main regulator. At the height of the civil war Sri Lanka was one of the most dangerous places for journalists. Prior to January 2015, violence against journalists and media was at a peak. From 2004 to 2015, more than 20 journalists and media assistants had been assassinated. Nearly all such crimes remain unpunished.

In 2018, the media market was highly concentrated. In the print media, the top four owners (the Wijewardene Family, the Government, the Welgama Family, and the Alles Family) had a combined readership share of 75 percent, posing a high risk of media politicization. The top four owners in the television market (the Rajamahendran Family, Dilith Jayaweera & Varuni Fernando, Rayynor Silva and the Government) together accounted for a viewer share of 77 percent. In the radio sector, concentration with the top four owners (Rayynor Silva, the Rajamahendran Family, Dilith Jayaweera & Varuni Amunugama and Nihal Seneviratne Epa) accounted for a listenership share of 74 percent. These tendencies undermine pluralism and impartiality and pose a high risk to media diversity.

Conclusion

The media should factually report public opinion. However, as the media industry grows, it becomes economically less viable for it to remain the watchdog of the government.  As the quality and educational value of news are degraded, the quality and value of politics also degrade. Further regulation of media ownership may be a solution; however, the governments have been moving in the other direction.

The media has the power to influence the public not only through creating opinions, but focusing people’s attention on certain problems. The rise of social media is often hailed as the rise of a democratic and participatory economy. However, these social media constantly monitor user interests such as their usage and browsing behaviour, demographics, generated content, social relations etc.

Therefore, we need to discover our own alternative media with community participation and civil society involvement. If independent media organisations could be supported and our own cooperative media organisations could be created that will represent our interests, we would be able to promote democratic, secular politics and scientific values in society. This will be possible only by establishing forms of people’s media, free from corporate control.

27 May 2021

Appeal to end the forced cremation of COVID-19 victims in Sri Lanka - 1 January 2021

 

Date: 1 January 2021

The Rt Hon Patricia Scotland QC

Secretary General

The Commonwealth of Nations

Appeal to end the forced cremation of COVID-19 victims in Sri Lanka

Dear Secretary-General

We write to bring to your notice a cold-hearted directive by the Government of Sri Lanka with regard to the disposal of bodies of COVID-19 victims which is in breach of fundamental human rights, particularly the religious and cultural rights, of Sri Lanka’s Muslim and Christian communities.

On 31 March of this year, the Government amended the ‘Provisional Clinical Practice Guidelines on COVID-19 Suspected and Confirmed Patients’ by adding a new clause that read “The body should be cremated within 24 hours (preferably within 12 hours)”. The abrupt change – made without any community consultation, or proven medical or scientific justification – renders cremation as the only means to dispose of the bodies of COVID-19 victims.

The practice of cremation is in violation of the fundamental teachings of Islam that prohibits cremation which is believed to be a desecration of the deceased. This authoritarian and insensitive action by the Government has caused immense pain and anguish among Islamic and Christian religious followers. Their traditional and cultural practice is to bury their dead after administering the last rites in accordance with the beliefs of the deceased and their communities of faith.

The Government’s ‘pseudoscience’ explanation is that the ground water will be contaminated if the bodies of the COVID-19 victims are buried underground – a claim totally rejected by most of the professionals competent in the fields of Virology, Epidemiology and Geology in the country. The so-called Expert Committee formed by the government to advise on the matter, clearly lacks the presence of competent virologists and epidemiologists, and has produced no scientific evidence that proves the occurrence of such contamination.

Out of desperation and as a mark of protest many families have refused to sign on papers that consent to cremation, and abandoned the corpses in the hospitals and police morgues rather than going against their religious beliefs. Consequently, the bodies are kept in morgues for lengthy periods and cremated at the sole discretion of the powers that be. This is in total disregard to and in violation of the guidelines set out by the World Health Organization. Furthermore, fearing the likelihood of cremation, some members of the Muslim community are not presenting themselves for treatment, making the task of pandemic control even more difficult for the health authorities.

Recently, members of Muslim and Christian communities went to the Supreme Court of the country to have their constitutionally guaranteed rights upheld. Yet, the Court refused to hear the 11 applications without giving any reason. This creates a worrisome situation where the affected communities and families have exhausted all legal avenues to obtain justice through the legal system in the country.

The practice also goes against minority rights, which are protected by international conventions and declarations ratified by Sri Lanka. The United Nations and several of its affiliated mandates such as the OHCHR, Special Repertoires, as well as many international organisations such as the Organization for Islamic Cooperation, Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch and others have condemned the practice of forced cremation as a serious violation of human rights.

The public outcry not only by Muslims but also Buddhists, Hindus and Christians, have done little to change the Government’s hard-line approach. Attempts by civil society activists, politicians, and other organisations to seek redress from the highest court in the land, too, have proved futile. And most civil society organisations see this as nothing but racial discrimination, particularly against the Muslims.

In the circumstances, we the following organisations, appeal to the Commonwealth of Nations to persuade the Government of Sri Lanka to withdraw the compulsory instruction to cremate all COVID-19 victims in Sri Lanka. This is an arbitrary process which is neither based on science nor recommended by the WHO, nor even adopted by countries such as the USA, Italy, Brazil, India, UK and Mexico – all of which have suffered much higher number of deaths from the pandemic.

The trauma experienced by the minorities of Sri Lanka as a result of this most unethical, insensitive and vexing governmental action is causing resentment, disharmony and unrest in the country.

Thank you for your urgent attention to this matter.

Yours faithfully,

On behalf of the Signatories

Dr Lionel Bopage

President

Australian Advocacy for Good Governance in Sri Lanka

Melbourne, Australia

--------------------

Signatories:

Assn of United Sri Lankan Australian Muslims of Western Australia Inc. (AUSLAMWA)    Mr Muzny Mohideen - President

Austra Lanka Muslim Association Inc. (ALMA)                                                                    Mr Ubaidur R Mahmood - President

Australian Advocacy for Good Governance in Sri Lanka (AAGGSL)                                   Dr Lionel Bopage - President

Australian National Imams Council (ANIC)                                                                          Imam Shadi Alsuleiman - President

Bridging Lanka Limited (BLL)                                                                                               Mr Jeremy A Liyanage – Exec. Director

Darebin Ethnic Communities Council Inc. (DECC)                                                              Mr Nalliah Suriyakumaran - Chair

Islamic Council of Victoria (ICV)                                                                                          Dr Mohamed Mohideen - President

Melbourne Human Rights Forum (MHRF)                                                                           Mr A. J. Shahim – Chief Coordinator

Muslim Information Network of Australasia Inc. (MINA)                                                      Mr Noor Mohamed - President

National Council of Churches in Australia (NCCA)                                                             Bishop Philip Huggins - President

Noorul-Islam Society                                                                                                           Mr Aghmed Edries - President

People for Human Rights and Equality (PHRE)                                                                 Dr Brian Jeganathan - President

Sri Lanka Invites (SLI)                                                                                                        Mr Larry Marshall - Coordinator

United Sri Lankan Muslim Association of Australia (USMAA)                                            Mr Falih Sums - President

Uniting Church Synod of Victoria and Tasmania (UCA Synod)                                          Rev Dev Anandarajan – Minister

Whittlesea Tamil Association (WTA)                                                                                   Mr Edward Mariathasan - President